Is Your Higher Ed Website Meeting Gen Z’s Expectations?

Audit your higher ed website with this self-assessment. Get tips for digital fundraising, mobile UX, and AI discoverability to engage Gen Z students and alumni.

Anne Stefanyk

Published: 

April 23, 2026

Updated: 

Summary

• Boost young alumni giving by integrating digital wallets like Apple Pay or Google Pay: Make it possible for donors to complete a gift in under 60 seconds to reduce friction and encourage participation.

‍
• Build trust with Gen Z by ditching stock photos and embracing real, unposed visuals: Showcase user-generated content and individual student stories on your website to demonstrate authenticity.

‍
• Shift your fundraising appeals to focus on individual impact, not just institutional progress: Instead of general requests, share specific stories of how donations help real students, which resonates strongly with Gen Z.

‍
• Make it simple for young alumni to find and register for events they care about: Clearly display networking opportunities, career support, and social events on your website to foster community and engagement.

‍
• Consider using AI to personalize the website experience for returning visitors: Greet alumni with custom dashboards and relevant content to show you understand their current needs and career stages, boosting engagement.

‍
• Optimize your website content for AI search engines with conversational keywords: This ensures your institution is discoverable by Gen Z students using tools like ChatGPT for their college search.

Gen Z is the generation born between 1997 and 2012. As current high school students, college students, and young alumni, Gen Z is the prime audience for your university’s digital content. But is your higher education website meeting their needs effectively?

The top college websites are user-friendly, accessible, mobile-compatible, and unique. They offer the authenticity that students and young alumni need to feel strongly connected to their alma mater. If your website isn’t clearing that bar, it could be time for a Gen Z-focused reset.

A Gen Z-friendly website is especially important as more Gen Z members become young alumni. Gen Z's philanthropic engagement has increased by 22% since 2021, making your young alumni a key audience for your university's fundraising efforts.

Below, we’ve created a self-assessment tool with questions to help you determine whether your website is meeting the needs of your Gen Z audience, organized by key website features. Use these guiding questions and tips to help you determine your website’s current state and growth path.

1. Visual authenticity and social proof

Morning Consult’s Most Trusted Universities report found that, among the four generations surveyed (including Millennials, Gen Z, and Baby Boomers), Gen Z is the least likely to trust higher education institutions. As your digital home, your higher education website is among your strongest tools for building trust with Gen Z students and alumni.

Does your homepage feature user-generated content (UGC) or raw videos from current students and young alumni?

Gen Z craves social proof in the form of unfiltered reality rather than curated experiences. Your website should appeal to that preference by:

  • Avoiding stock photos and instead only using authentic, unposed photographs of students and campus life.
  • Incorporating user-generated content via a social media widget on your homepage that pulls in real-time Instagram or TikTok content from campus.
  • Adding “day in the life” content to your blog posts and social media pages, where student ambassadors can take over posting for a day, and show what their daily activities look like.

These content strategies ensure your digital presence reflects and prioritizes student voices.

Are your impact stories focused on individual narratives rather than institutional progress?

Young alumni donors want to see the immediate, tangible impact their contributions will have before deciding to give or engage with your alumni giving program. To meet Gen Z's demand for authenticity, impact stories should focus on individual stories rather than general institutional updates.

For example, avoid generic, nebulous fundraising requests like “Please give to our annual fund.” Instead, send an email asking young alumni to “Help first-generation student Sarah fund essential cancer research to complete her senior thesis.” The second option pulls potential Gen Z donors directly into the story of a real student on your campus who needs help.

2. Mobile-first functionality and seamless giving

Your higher education website must be fully mobile-optimized, as a Harmony Healthcare IT survey found that Gen Z spends an average of 6 hours and 27 minutes on their phones every day.

A seamless, mobile-optimized giving experience is an essential step toward making alumni giving more convenient and less intimidating for Gen Z.

Are your overall website and donation page mobile-optimized?

Your website should look good on any device, whether visitors are using a laptop, an Android device, or an iPhone. Keep these elements in mind when optimizing your website for mobile devices:

  • Large, readable fonts
  • Stackable content structures, such as hamburger menus
  • Properly spaced tap targets like buttons and links
  • Robust text-to-give capabilities for immediate, personal communication

Your institution can further enhance engagement by creating mobile-friendly online forums or Facebook groups to foster a sense of community among young alumni.

Can a donor complete a gift in under 60 seconds using a digital wallet?

Digital wallets such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal are now the third most popular way donors give to nonprofits, surpassing traditional methods like checks.

If your donation checkout process requires entering a 16-digit credit card number and a billing address, Gen Z members won’t take the time to complete their transactions. Integrate one-touch payment options via digital wallets to reduce friction and increase young alumni giving.

3. AI-ready infrastructure and discoverability

An EAB survey found that nearly half of high school students now use AI tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini during their college search, a sharp increase from 26 percent in spring 2025. If your website is invisible to AI search tools, it’s invisible to potential applicants.

Is your content structured for generative engine optimization (GEO)?

GEO is the term for optimizing a website to appear in generative AI search engines for specific queries. Users tend to interact with AI-powered search tools much more conversationally than with traditional search platforms, because they can ask multi-part questions and receive personalized answers.

To ensure your website appears for highly-targeted searches, Kanopi Studios’ guide to AI for higher education recommends providing “specific information on your website that highlights your unique credentials and offerings.”

For example, if your coastal university wants to increase traffic from potential applicants looking for schools by the beach, you could include keywords such as “universities with the best ocean views” and “colleges 30 minutes from the beach” on your student life page.

Do you use AI-driven personalization to greet returning alumni or students?

The National Alumni Survey discovered that only 14% of alumni believe their institution has a good understanding of their current career or life stage. Increase alumni engagement and retention by creating secure portals where they can log in and see personalized gated content, such as a custom alumni or student dashboard that displays relevant information, deadlines, and upcoming events.

4. Communication and ongoing engagement

Potential and current students, as well as young alumni, want to feel included in your university’s community. They want real-time, transparent information to help them navigate your application process, student life, or the post-grad experience.

Does your website address the causes and topics Gen Z cares about?

Higher education website design and development isn’t just about how your website looks. Gen Z wants to find answers and information about the questions and causes they care most about, such as:

  • Resources for underrepresented students
  • Mental health services and resources for students
  • Clarity on DEI initiatives and racial equity
  • Campus safety
  • Environmental sustainability
  • Information about the university’s position on using AI in the classroom

Don’t make website visitors hunt for this information. Use your main navigation menu to share links to essential resources, including your campus security details, environmental sustainability reports, and DEI policies.

Is it easy to find event opportunities on your website?

The National Alumni Survey found that the vast majority of alumni (86 percent) are very satisfied or satisfied with their student experience, but just 50 percent feel very satisfied or satisfied with their alumni experience. This stark contrast highlights a critical gap that higher education websites can easily address by improving event discoverability.

Though considered a digital-native generation, Gen Z alumni actually crave community. They rank networking opportunities, career support, and sporting events as the three most valuable services offered by their alma mater, demonstrating a clear desire for engagement. By spotlighting relevant event opportunities, your website can help them find their alumni niche.

Make it easy for Gen Z website visitors to find opportunities to connect, such as fundraising events, sporting events, networking meetups, and giving days, on your online calendar. Ensure your calendar offers all the need-to-know information for each event, including how to register, date, time, location, and any associated costs. Additionally, to fully support their desire for community and career development, offer clear information about local alumni groups to join, virtual career prep panels and webinars, and mentorship opportunities with current students.

So, how did you do? If you answered yes most of the time, congratulations; your website is probably in pretty good shape for engaging Gen Z. If you had a few more nos than you’d like, don’t panic. Start by addressing your site’s infrastructure, ensuring it's mobile-friendly and optimized for AI search. Then, build on your approach by layering in the personalization, community-building, and authenticity that Gen Z is looking for. As a result, you’ll be able to build a website that engages your core audience and helps them feel at home with your university.

Table of Contents

Subscribe

See how modern advancement teams bring alumni engagement and fundraising together.

Plan faster. Execute better

Explore free templates designed for alumni and fundraising teams.

Anne Stefanyk

Anne Stefanyk is the Founder and CEO of Kanopi Studios, a leading digital agency that designs and builds websites for mission-driven organizations. With deep expertise in strategy, user experience, and open-source technologies, Anne has guided Kanopi to become a trusted partner to nonprofits, higher education, and healthcare institutions.

Since launching Kanopi in 2010, Anne has fostered a people-first culture and a strong commitment to accessible, sustainable web practices. Her team creates inclusive digital experiences that help organizations make meaningful impact.

‍

Get a closer look at how modern advancement teams use Almabase to engage, raise, and retain

Book a demo